The Korean War and the Armistice: Assessments of American Experts of 1953
- Identificator
- EDN: JHUFBT ; УДК 94(519)“1950/1953”
- Authors
- Rychkova Olga Vladimirovna, PhD in History, associate professor of the Department of History and Political Science, Vyatka State University. Russia, Kirov. ResearcherID: QKY-0420-2026. ORCID: 0000-0002-9468-6562. E-mail: olya.rychkova@gmail.com
- Journal
- HERALD OF HUMANITARIAN EDUCATION №3 (43) 2026
- Section
- GENERAL HISTORY
- Pages
- 81-94
- Abstract
-
Under the conditions of the unfolding Cold War, the events in Korea in 1950–1953 became an important element of media attention in the United States. Unlike the news publications, the professional American journals showed rigor in their assessments of these events. The signing of the Panmunjom Armistice and the renewed interest of readers in the region led to a particular demand for the work of professional analysts (diplomats, politicians, military men, political observers, and special correspondents). The article presents an analysis of how the leading experts of the USA interpreted the key events of the conflict. The approaches of the press to the origins of the war are examined, and the role of the ideological confrontation of the superpowers and of the concept of "the containment of communism" is emphasized. Attention is paid to the differences in the interpretations of the significance of the Soviet and the American factors in the Korean events. The coverage by the mass media of the participation of the United Nations in the conflict, of the degree of that organization's independence, and of the effectiveness of the actions of the troops of its coalition is analyzed. The key arguments that the US press advanced in explanation of the reasons for the conclusion of the armistice are studied: from the strategic deadlock at the front and the enormous human losses to the domestic political pressure on the Eisenhower administration. Attention is paid to the forecasts of American specialists regarding the future of the Korean Peninsula. The author examines how the understanding was formed in media discourse that the armistice was not a final peace but only a temporary stabilization. The conclusion is substantiated that the materials of the American mass media make it possible to trace the mechanisms of interaction between the press and the authorities under the conditions of the Cold War.
- Keywords
-
the Korean War
armistice
the foreign policy of the USSR
NATO
the UN
Panmunjom
the Cold War
mass media
- Recieved
-
31.08.2026
- Published
-
19.11.2026
References
- Bogaturov A. D. Korejskij vopros v otnosheniyah mezhdu vedushchimi derzhavami [The Korean Question in the Relations among the Leading Powers] // Sistemnaya istoriya mezhdunarodnyh otnoshenij : v 2 t. T. 2 [A Systemic History of International Relations : in 2 vols. Vol. 2]. M., Kul'turnaya revolyuciya (Cultural Revolution), 2007. 717 p.
- Vanin Yu. V. Korejskaya vojna i OON [The Korean War and the UN]. M., Institut vostokovedeniya RAN (Institute of Oriental Studies of the RAS), 2006. 286 p.
- Korejskoe uregulirovanie i interesy Rossii [The Korean Settlement and the Interests of Russia] / ed. by V. I. Denisov, A. Z. Zhebin. M., Russkaya panorama (Russian Panorama), 2008. 343 p.
- Mazulov V. M. Yuzhnaya Koreya i vneshnyaya politika SShA [South Korea and the Foreign Policy of the USA]. M., Nauka (Sciences), 1971. 268 p.
- Petuhov V. I. U istokov bor'by za edinstvo i nezavisimost' Korei [At the Origins of the Struggle for the Unity and Independence of Korea]. M., Nauka (Sciences), 1987. 239 p.
- Shabshina F. I. Ocherki novejshej istorii Korei (1945–1953 gg.) [Essays on the Contemporary History of Korea (1945–1953)]. M., Gospolitizdat, 1958. 307 p.
- Yungblyud V. T., Sadakov D. A. Diplomaticheskoe obespechenie vmeshatel'stva SShA v Korejskuyu vojnu. Opyt krizisnogo reagirovaniya [The Diplomatic Support of the US Intervention in the Korean War. The Experience of Crisis Response] // Vestnik MGIMO-Universiteta – MGIMO Review of International Relations. 2018. No. 4 (61). P. 257. DOI: 10.24833/2071-8160-2018-4-61-241-261.
- Acheson D. Present at the Creation. My Years in State Department. N. Y. : W. W. Norton, 1969. 853 p.
- Altstedter N. Problems of Coalition Diplomacy: The Korean Experience // International Journal. 1953. Vol. 8. Autumn. № 4. Pp. 256–265.
- Armstrong H. F. The Grand Alliance Hesitates // Foreign Affairs. 1953. Vol. 32. October. № 1. Pp. 48–67. DOI: 10.2307/20031007.
- Armstrong H. F. The World Is Round // Foreign Affairs. 1953. Vol. 31. January. № 2. Pp. 175–199. DOI: 10.2307/20030953.
- Asirvatham E. Is Peace Possible? // The Indian Journal of Political Science. 1953. Vol. 14. April-June. № 2. Pp. 131–144.
- Bauer R. A. The Implications of the Succession Crisis in the Soviet Union for East-West Relations // Social Problems. 1953. Vol. 1. October. № 2. Pp. 38–43. DOI: 10.2307/798598.
- Bohlen C. Witness to history. 1929–1969. N. Y. : W. W. Norton, 1973. 620 p.
- Bretton H. L. The German Social Democratic Party and the International Situation // The American Political Science Review. 1953. Vol. 47. December. № 4. Pp. 980–996. DOI: 10.2307/1951120.
- Calendar of Events since Stalin's Death and Points to be Considered by Ministers- NATO Archives Online archives.nato.int/calendar-of-events-since-stalins-death-and-points-to-be-considered-by-ministers Memorandum of Discussion at a Special Meeting of the National Security Council on Tuesday, March 31, 1953. URL: https://nsarchive.gwu.edu/document/16064-document-03-memorandum-discussion (date accessed: 02.05.2026).
- Dean A. The Role of the United States in the Far East, 1954) // The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1954. Vol. 294: America and a New Asia. July. Pp. 48–55.
- Deutscher I. The Beria Affair // International Journal. 1953. Vol. 8. Autumn. № 4. Pp. 227–239.
- Donovan W. J. Strategic Services in Cold War' // Naval War College Review. September. 1953. Vol. 6. September. № 1. Pp. 31–42.
- Dulles J. F. Policy for Security and Peace // Foreign Affairs. 1954. Vol. 32. April. № 3. Pp. 353–364. DOI: 10.2307/20031035.
- Eddy A. Is Peace Possible? // The Indian Journal of Political Science. 1953. Vol. 14. April – June. № 2. Pp. 131–144.
- Eisenhower D. Mandate for change, 1953–1956. N. Y. : Garden City, N. Y., Doubleday, 1963. 713 p.
- Fleet J. A. van. The Truth About Korea // Life. 1953. Vol. 34. 11 May. № 19. Pp. 126–141.
- Fleming D. F. The Failure of Western Policies // The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1953. Vol. 288: NATO and World Peace. July. Pp. 36–46.
- Foreign Relations of the United States. Vol. XV. 1952–1954, Korea. P. 1. Washington, D. C. : U. S. Government Printing Office, 1984. 1192 p.
- Foreword // World Affairs. 1953: Fall. Vol. 116. № 3. P. 66.
- Goodrich L. M. United Nations: Success or Failure? // Proceedings of the Academy of Political Science. 1953. Vol. 25. January. № 2. Pp. 90–104.
- Greene Fr. Neutralization and the Balance of Power // The American Political Science Review. 1953. Vol. 47. December. № 4. Pp. 1058–1075. DOI: 10.2307/1951124.
- Hartmann Fr. H. The Renewal of Multi-Power Diplomacy // The Antioch Review. 1953. Vol. 13. Winter. № 4. Pp. 443–454.
- Hornbeck S. K. Korea – In Perspective // World Affairs. 1953. Vol. 116. Summer. № 2. Pp. 35–38.
- Huston J. A. Germany, Another Korea? // World Affairs. 1953. Fall. Vol. 116. № 3. Pp. 69–71.
- Kersten Ch. J. The Liberation Policy and International Order // The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1953. Vol. 288: NATO and World Peace. July. Pp. 93–104.
- Leckie R. Conflict: The History of the Korean War. N. Y. : Putnam, 1962. 488 p.
- Lewis H. R. Industrial Capacity and Its Utilization // Science & Society. 1953. Fall. Vol. 17. № 4. Pp. 318–325.
- Lundin C. E., Jr. Repatriation of Prisoners of War: The Legal and Political Aspects // American Bar Association Journal. 1953. Vol. 39. July. № 7. Pp. 559–563.
- Manly Ch. The Truth about the United Nation // American Mercury. 1953. Vol. 76. Pp. 87–96.
- Matthews J. B. Communists and the New Deal. Part III // American Mercury. 1953. Vol. 76. August. Pp. 17–25.
- Millis W. Military Problems of the New Administration // Foreign Affairs. 1953. Vol. 31. January. № 2. Pp. 215–224. DOI: 10.2307/20030955.
- Mosely Ph. E. The Kremlin's Foreign Policy since Stalin // Foreign Affairs. 1953. Vol. 32. October. № 1. Pp. 20–33. DOI: 10.2307/20031005.
- Oppenheimer J. R. Atomic Weapons and American Policy // Foreign Policy. 1953. Vol. 31. July. № 4. Pp. 525–535. DOI: 10.2307/20030987.
- Palmer N. D. Factors Shaping Postwar United States Policy Toward China // India Quarterly. 1953. Vol. 9. July – September. № 3. Pp. 227–248.
- Palmer N. D. The Far East: Lack of Understanding // Current History. 1953. Vol. 25. October. № 146. Pp. 242–249.
- Potter P. B. Repatriation of Korean Prisoners of War // The American Journal of International Law. 1953. Vol. 47. October. № 4. Pp. 661–662.
- Rees D. Korea: The Limited War. N. Y. : St Martin's Press, 1964. 552 p.
- Schwartz D. F. Blueprint for Conquest // American Mercury. 1953. Vol. 77. August. Pp. 83–87.
- Selected List of Soviet Moves since Stalin's Death on 5-mar-53-NATO. Archives Online. Available at: archives.nato.int/uploads/r/nato-archives-online/4/7/a/47a809ba6ddefc2f57e2ba9c820df9de774ddb83685963d29 420af6f51937623/AC_34-D_15_ENG_NHQL742870.pdf (date accessed: 05.05.2026).
- Stuek W. The Korean War: An International History. Princeton, N. J. : Princeton University Press, 1995. 506 p.
- Suchman E. A., Goldsen R. K., Williams, Jr. R. M. Attitudes Toward the Korean War // The Public Opinion Quarterly. 1953. Vol. 17. Summer. № 2. Pp. 171–184.
- Taubenfeld H. J. International Actions and Neutrality // The American Journal of International Law. 1953. Vol. 47. July. № 3. Pp. 377–396.
- Taurer B. Stalin's Last Thesis // Foreign Affairs. 1953. Vol. 31. April. № 3. Pp. 367–381. DOI: 10.2307/20030971.
- The Gallup Poll: Public Opinion, 1935–1971. Vol. 2: 1949–1958. N. Y. : Random House, 1972. 1584 p.
- Thompson K. W. Collective Security Reexamined // The American Political Science Review. 1953. Vol. 47. September. № 3. Pp. 753–772. DOI: 10.2307/1952903.
- Truman H. S. Memoirs by Harry S. Truman: years of trial and hope. N. Y. : New American Library, 1965. 620 p.
- U. S. Congress. Congressional Record. Proceedings and debates of the 83th Congress. First session. February 26 – April 8, 1953. Vol. 99, Part 2. Washington, D. C. : U. S. Government Printing Office, 1953. 1409 p.
- U. S. Congress. Congressional Record. Proceedings and debates of the 83th Congress. First session. May 01–27, 1953. Vol. 99, Part 4. Washington, D. C. : U. S. Government Printing Office, 1953. 1483 p.
- U. S. Congress. Congressional Record. Proceedings and debates of the 83th Congress. First session. June 25 – July 11, 1953. Vol. 99, Part 6. Washington, D. C. : U. S. Government Printing Office, 1953. 1363 p.
- Utley Fr. Facing the Facts in Germany // American Mercury. 1953. Vol. 76. June. Pp. 112–118.
- Warburg J. P. Which way to Liberation? // The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science. 1953. Vol. 288: NATO and World Peace. July. Pp. 82–92.
- Wells K. M. Korea: Outline of a Civilization. Boston : Brill, 2015. 327 p.
- Wolfe B. D. Totalitarianism and History // The Antioch Review. 1953. Vol. 13. Summer. № 2. Pp. 155–165.
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License