"It Is Grievous, Sad, and Bitter in the Heart of a Patriot": The Russo-Japanese War in Letters to Saint John of Kronstadt
- Identificator
- EDN: GMXTPB ; УДК 94(47). 073
- Authors
- Orlov Maksim Aleksandrovich, PhD in History, Petersburg Lyceum. Russia, Kirov. ORCID: 0000-0003-4663-9443. E-mail: orlov.m.a.87@yandex.ru
- Journal
- HERALD OF HUMANITARIAN EDUCATION №3 (43) 2026
- Section
- NATIONAL HISTORY
- Pages
- 35-44
- Abstract
-
The Russo-Japanese War of 1904–1905 became a multidimensional conflict in which military events and the internal political development of the Russian Empire were closely intertwined. The article for the first time introduces into scholarly circulation letters to John of Kronstadt written to him in connection with the events of the Russo-Japanese War. In the historiography, John of Kronstadt's correspondence relating to the events of this war has not yet been studied. The large number of letters sent to John of Kronstadt during the war with Japan was due to the considerable authority this priest acquired at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries. In his sermons and written epistles, John of Kronstadt regularly addressed the events in the Far East and shaped in people his own vision of the confrontation between Russia and Japan. For this reason, the authors of the letters frequently display similar views of the war. An analysis of the documents has made it possible to identify the images of the war: of Russia, of Japan, of the emperor, and of John of Kronstadt himself. The perception of the military conflict is a kind of mirror reflecting the letter-writers' conceptions of authority and of the clergy (on the example of John of Kronstadt). It is shown that at the beginning of the 20th century most people had a vague notion of Japan. The Russo-Japanese War was closely connected with the revolutionary events of 1905, and therefore John of Kronstadt's correspondents compared the Russo-Japanese War with the First Russian Revolution. A distinctive feature of the letters is that they contain almost no criticism of the authorities for the failures in the war with the Japanese. Defeats are regarded as God's punishment for the sins of the people. Such a view of the war was characteristic of John of Kronstadt himself.
- Keywords
-
the Russo-Japanese War
John of Kronstadt
Port Arthur
military psychology
the image of war
- Recieved
-
26.02.2026
- Published
-
19.11.2026
References
- Bol'shakov N. I. Istochnik zhivoj vody. Zhizneopisanie svyatogo pravednogo otca Ioanna Kronshtadtskogo [The Source of Living Water. A Life of the Holy Righteous Father John of Kronstadt]. SPb., Carskoe delo, 1995. 855 p.
- Vorob'eva E. A. "Prekrasnaya strana Yaponiya, prekrasnaya strana Rossiya": formirovanie i vospriyatie obraza vraga ["Beautiful Japan, Beautiful Russia": The Formation and Perception of the Image of the Enemy] // Idei i idealy – Ideas and Ideals. 2018. No. 1, Vol. 1. Pp. 164–182.
- Gromyko M. M., Buganov A. V. O vozzreniyah russkogo naroda [On the Views of the Russian People]. M., Palomnik, 2000. 541 p.
- Zhukova L. V. Vospriyatie Yaponii v Rossii nakanune Russko-yaponskoj vojny [The Perception of Japan in Russia on the Eve of the Russo-Japanese War] // Rossiya i mir glazami drug druga: iz istorii vzaimovospriyatiya : sb. st. [Russia and the World Through Each Other's Eyes: From the History of Mutual Perception : A Collection of Articles]. M., ROSSPEN, 2002. Is. 2. Pp. 341–356.
- Il'yashenko F. A. Otec Ioann Kronshtadtskij v vospriyatii sovremennikov : dis. … kand. ist. nauk [Father John of Kronstadt in the Perception of His Contemporaries : dis. ... PhD in History]. M., 2004. 225 p.
- Ioann Kronshtadtskij. Put' k Bogu [John of Kronstadt. The Path to God] // Ioann Kronshtadtskij : sb. [John of Kronstadt : A Collection] / comp. by V. A. Desyatnikov. M., 1992. Pp. 129–176.
- Ioann Kronshtadtskij. Neizdannyj dnevnik. Vospominaniya episkopa Arseniya ob otce Ioanne Kronshtadtskom [John of Kronstadt. An Unpublished Diary. Bishop Arseny's Reminiscences of Father John of Kronstadt]. M., Blagotvoritel'noe bratstvo vo imya Vsemilostivogo Spasa, 1992. 59 p.
- Kicenko N. B. Svyatoj nashego vremeni: otec Ioann Kronshtadtskij i russkij narod [A Saint of Our Time: Father John of Kronstadt and the Russian People]. M., Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2006. 390 p.
- Konovalova N. A. Obraz samoderzhaviya v predstavleniyah russkogo krest'yanstva po fol'klornym materialam [The Image of Autocracy in the Conceptions of the Russian Peasantry According to Folklore Materials] // Vestnik Omskogo universiteta – Herald of Omsk University. 2007. No. 4. Pp. 121–126.
- Laryuel' M. "Zheltaya opasnost'" v rabotah russkih nacionalistov [Laruelle M. The "Yellow Peril" in the Works of Russian Nationalists] // Russko-yaponskaya vojna 1904–1905. Vzglyad cherez stoletie : mezhdunar. ist. sb. [The Russo-Japanese War of 1904–1905. A View Across a Century : An International Historical Collection] / ed. by O. R. Ajrapetov. M., Tri kvadrata, 2004. Pp. 579–591.
- Novikova S. A. Obraz vojny v voennyh korrespondenciyah i publicistike Vas. I. Nemirovicha-Danchenko v period russko-tureckoj (1877–1878) i russko-yaponskoj (1904–1905) vojn: syuzhety i rol' obshchestvennyh stereotipov v ego formirovanii [The Image of War in the War Correspondence and Journalism of Vas. I. Nemirovich-Danchenko During the Russo-Turkish (1877–1878) and Russo-Japanese (1904–1905) Wars: Plots and the Role of Social Stereotypes in Its Formation] // Vestnik PSTGU. Seriya Istoriya. Istoriya Russkoj Pravoslavnoj Cerkvi – St. Tikhon's University Review. Series: History. History of the Russian Orthodox Church. 2014. Is. 1 (56). Pp. 84–96.
- Odincov M. I. Ioann Kronshtadtskij [John of Kronstadt]. M., Molodaya gvardiya (The Young Guard), 2014. 349 p.
- Prebyvanie ikony "Torzhestvo Presvyatye Bogorodicy" v gor. Vladivostoke i otpravleniya ee v Port-Artur [The Stay of the Icon "The Triumph of the Most Holy Mother of God" in the City of Vladivostok and Its Dispatch to Port Arthur] // Vladivostokskie eparhial'nye vedomosti – Vladivostok Diocesan Gazette. 1905. No. 2. Pp. 31–36.
- RSHA (Russian State Historical Archive). F. 796. Op. 442. D. 2290.
- RSHA. F. 1622. Op. 1. D. 470.
- Svyatoj pravednyj Ioann Kronshtadtskij : dnevnik. T. 26 [Saint John of Kronstadt the Righteous : A Diary. Vol. 26]. M., Svyato-Troickaya Sergieva Lavra, 2020. 343 p.
- Senyavskaya E. S. Psihologiya vojny v XX veke: istoricheskij opyt Rossii [The Psychology of War in the 20th Century: The Historical Experience of Russia]. M., ROSSPEN, 1999. 382 p.
- Senyavskaya E. S. Chelovek na vojne: opyt istoriko-psihologicheskoj harakteristiki rossijskogo kombatanta [Man at War: An Attempt at a Historical-Psychological Characterization of the Russian Combatant] // Otechestvennaya istoriya – Russian History. 1995. No. 3. Pp. 7–16.
- Serbinenko V. G. Vojna v vozzreniyah svyatogo pravednogo Ioanna Kronshtadtskogo [War in the Views of Saint John of Kronstadt the Righteous] // Tradicii i novacii v sovremennom kul'turno-obrazovatel'nom prostranstve vektor razvitiya : sb. materialov nauch.-prakt. konf., Shuya, 15 maya 2025 g. [Traditions and Innovations in the Contemporary Cultural and Educational Space: A Vector of Development : Proceedings of a Scientific-Practical Conference, Shuya, May 15, 2025]. Shuya, Shujskij filial IvGU, 2025. Pp. 52–55.
- Starovojtova E. O. Kitaj v rossijskoj satiricheskoj presse vremen Russko-yaponskoj vojny [China in the Russian Satirical Press of the Russo-Japanese War Period] // Novejshaya istoriya Rossii – Modern History of Russia. 2021. Vol. 11, No. 4. Pp. 1023–1044.
- Suvorin A. S. Russko-yaponskaya vojna i russkaya revolyuciya. Malen'kie pis'ma (1904–1908) [The Russo-Japanese War and the Russian Revolution. Little Letters (1904–1908)]. M., 2005. 572 p.
- Surskij I. K. Otec Ioann Kronshtadtskij [Father John of Kronstadt]. M., Otchij dom, 2008. 719 p.
- Hlodov V. A. Russko-yaponskaya vojna 1904–1905 gg. v vospriyatii naseleniya Orlovskoj gubernii (po dannym orlovskoj pressy) [The Russo-Japanese War of 1904–1905 in the Perception of the Population of Oryol Province (According to the Oryol Press)] // Uchenye zapiski Orlovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Seriya: Gumanitarnye i social'nye nauki – Scientific Notes of Oryol State University. Series: Humanities and Social Sciences. 2011. No. 4 (42). Pp. 111–123.
- CSHA SPb (Central State Historical Archive of St. Petersburg). F. 2219. Op. 1. D. 1.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. D. 14 b.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. D. 14 v.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. D. 30.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. Op. 1. D. 34.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. Op. 1. D. 48.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. Op. 1. D. 50.
- CSHA SPb. F. 2219. Op. 1. D. 59.
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License